Planning the model
Previous Top Next

Decide what to model

Before a model can be planned, you must first be familiar with the types of modeling elements available.  A thermal model should first be planned on paper.  It should first be decided which geometry of the problem should be represented in the model.  Often details such as fillets, chamfers, small holes or radii do not have a thermal effect.  Therefore, they should not be represented in the model.  If in question, they may be included.  While planning the model, the resultant size of the model should be kept in mind.  Including details which may not have an impact on the results could make a model take exceedingly long to run.  Also associated with the size of the model is the accuracy of the results.  It is not always true that a larger model or finer mesh will result in a more accurate solution.  There is an optimum mesh size where creating a finer model will not alter the results.  This is ideally the size of model which should be created.  It is, though, not realistic to iterate refining the model until the solution no longer changes.  The proper mesh of the elements for a given model will only come with some experience.  With Solaria, a model having a finer mesh than necessary can easily be generated and solved quickly and is recommended for inexperienced users.

Decide how to represent the problem

After it is decided what geometry is to be modeled, the types of elements to be used should be planned.  Parts of the model where there is not expected to be a temperature gradient through it thickness should be modeled with plate elements.  This may be a copper layer in a multi-layer printed circuit board or the walls of an aluminum enclosure.  A symptom of a model where brick elements are used where the temperature gradient is extremely small compared with other gradients in the model is that it converges extremely slow when solving.  In this case, the brick elements should be replaced with plate elements.  Parts of the model where there are expected to be temperature gradients in all directions should be modeled with brick elements.  An aluminum rod on the other hand could be modeled with resistor elements.  The cross sectional area of the rod is defined when the element is generated and the property table is referenced.  In the property table, the thermal conductivity of the rod material is entered as Kx.

How many elements should a region be broken into

The mesh or the number of element an area is to broken into should next be planned.  Presently, in Solaria, the easiest mesh is a constant mesh in each direction.  When generating plate elements, the four corners or two diagonal corners of a region which is to be meshed is first defined with nodes.  The two or four nodes are selected and the region is meshed with an even mesh of elements in the X direction and an even mesh in the Y direction.  If the edge of the meshed region is to be connected to another region, the element mesh must be consistent between the two regions.  When meshed, the nodes generated at the common boundary should be coincident with a tolerance.  When the model is equivalenced, the nodes at the common boundary must be combined or there will not be thermal contact of the two regions.

·     First, layout the model based on geometric constraints
·     Make the model only as fine as geometry and accuracy requires
·     Make elements smaller in areas where high temperature gradients are expected.
·     Generate nodes at points where temperatures are of interest

How to construct the model

Prior to constructing the model, it should be analyzed to determine the best procedure in which it should be constructed.  There are many ways in which a model can be constructed.  Some are more efficient than others.  Copying and mirroring elements is far easier than generating nodes and then the elements.  In most cases, nodes need only be generated at the outset of the model generation.  After some initial geometry has been generated, these elements can be copied or mirrored to create additional geometry.  The new nodes can be moved to adjust dimensions if necessary.  The referenced element property table number can also be easily changed where necessary.

The following summarizes the typical sequence to generate a model;

·     Generate nodes at specific geometric locations
·     Generate modeling elements using nodes to define end or corner points of the elements (plates, bricks and resistors)
·     Use the Move, Copy, Rotate and Mirror options to expand the model
·     Add convection and/or radiation to plates or a specific face of brick elements
·     Equivalence and compact the model
·     Add heat loads to nodes, surface heat loads to plates or a specific face of brick elements or volumetric heat loads to brick or tetrahedron elements
·     Define the temperatures of boundary nodes
·     Add fluid flow elements where necessary
·     Enter data to the property table
·     Enter array data where the property, heat load or temperature is time or temperature dependent