Transient solution
Previous Top Next

Transient solution

Finite Difference Solver

Select Solve>Transient>Finite Diff or hit the graphic toolbar button.

graphic

Start Time

Enter the start time for the solution in the Start Time edit box.  This is typically 0.0.  If some properties are time dependent, then it may be desired to start the model at a time other than zero.

Defining a print interval

When a transient model is run, temperatures can be saved to disk at predefined points in time. The print times can be at constant and equal intervals for the entire solution or can vary during the solution.  It may be desired to print temperatures more often when a time dependent heat flux is at its peak.  The data is defined by defining a print interval and an end time for that interval.  To define a single print interval for the entire solution, enter the interval and the total run time for the model.  To define a time varying print interval, define pairs of data with the time value increasing. The last time value entered will be the total run time for the model.

RCmin factor

During transient runs, the RC product of all nodes is calculated.  This is to determine a stable computing interval for the run.  The calculated value is normally reduced by the default RCmin factor of 0.95 to ensure a stable solution.  Select the RCmin edit box and enter a new value. Smaller values may be necessary to reduce the computing interval for model with high RC products.  This may be necessary to capture a time varying occurrence defined in an array data set.  The value entered must be greater than zero and less than 1.0.

Variable property calculation interval

This option defines the number of iterations between the recalculation of temperature dependent heat loads and properties for steady state solutions.  Regardless of the setting, whenever the convergence is above 1.0, the temperature dependent heat loads and properties are updated every iteration.  After this, the defined interval is used.  If the interval is too large or the properties vary significantly with temperature a lower interval should be used.  When Solaria performs a recalculation, you will noticed that the convergence displayed on the screen will increase for several iterations and then continue to drop.  For transient solution, variable properties are calculated every iteration.

In the Max. Variable Resistance Iterations enter a iteration increment.  A typical value is 50.  If the problem has highly temperature dependent properties then a value of 1 should be used.  A lower value will only slightly slow the solution.

Initial Temperature

The Initial Temperature edit box is used to define the initial temperatures of all nodes except boundary nodes.  The user can uncheck the Use Current Temperature checkbox and enter a temperature in the Initial Temperature edit box.  If the Use Current Temperature checkbox is checked, temperatures presently assigned to the nodes will be used as the initial temperature for the nodes.  This is useful when it is desired to start a transient run with steady state temperatures as the initial temperatures.  The model can be run for steady state temperatures, the heat loads changed or removed, then the model run to determine cool down rate.

Results File Name

When a model is run for transient conditions, temperatures at all nodes in the model are written to disk at the print interval defined above.  This edit box is used to define the name for this file.  A file name can be entered or the button to the right of the edit box can be selected to define a name.  The file name must have the extension OUT to be read back into Solaria for post processing.

Arithmetic Nodes

An arithmetic node is one that does not have a thermal capacitance.  Select here to go to descriptions of the algorithms used during the transient solution.  If the property table referenced by a geometric element does not have specific heat or density defined then a capacitance value is not added to the nodes referenced by the elements.  During the solution arithmetic nodes are solved differently.  Three control parameters are provided for arithmetic nodes.  During each transient time step, arithmetic node temperatures are determined.  They are solved for in a very similar manner to the Solaria steady state solution. 

Hit the Solve button to solve the model.

Preconditioned Conjugate Gradient Solver

Select Solve>Transient>GCG or hit the graphic toolbar button.
graphic


Transient solution detailed example

The figure below is a model of a Gallium Arsenide (GaAs) RF amplifier.  The smallest dimension in this model is 0.03 microns.  The minimum thermal time constant is 1.56e-11 seconds.  To run this model for 0.002 seconds would require more than 128 million iterations using the finite difference solver.  This is an ideal application for the GCG solver.
graphic
graphic

The model was run for nine different settings in the GCG dialog.  The three Preconditioner options were tried and the Termination Criteria was tightened.  A single node at the heat source was plotted with time and the time to solve the transient was recorded.  The following table summarizes the results.  The temperature plot of the nine cases is shown in the figure below.  It is easily seen that, with the incorrect settings, very incorrect answers can be calculated.  It is therefore very important to verify that the solution is correct.  For a certain type of problem, once proper settings have been determined, they can be used later, on other similar problems without having to do this exercise. 

For this case, the default of five sub iterations for the SOR preconditioner is best.  Changing to two or ten sub iterations resulted in worse results.  As would be expected, the termination criteria are of most importance.  From the first order look, adding a single decimal place to the termination criteria improves the results significantly.  On looking closer though, see the figure below, there are oscillations in the solution.  The SOR and Jacobi give about the same answer for a termination criteria of 0.0001 but the Jacobi solves more than a minute faster.  The Jacobi preconditioner with a termination criteria of 0.000001 solves in about twelve minutes and provides the best answers. 

Termination criteria                                                                                            
Case    MAX(Abs(R))    ABD(Sum(R))    Time to solve    Name               Pre Conditioner
                                                             (seconds)         
1          0.001                0.01                  138                   0.001                SOR 5 sub it.
2          0.0001              0.001                264                   0.0001              SOR 5 sub it.
3          0.00001            0.0001              694                   0.00001            SOR 5 sub it.                
4          0.001                0.01                  208                   0.001                SOR 10 SOR 10 sub it.
5          0.001                0.01                  141                   SOR 2              SOR 2 sub it.     
6          0.001                0.01                  137                   Jacobi 0.001     Jacobi
7          0.0001              0.001                189                   Jacobi 0.0001   Jacobi
8          0.00001            0.0001              335                   Jacobi 0.00001  Jacobi  
9          0.000001          0.00001            719                   Jacobi 0.000001 Jacobi



graphic

graphic